I have students bring two copies of their rough drafts. While the students are doing their peer reviews, I scan the other copy, looking at the structure of the essays rather than proofreading them. The students are free to proofread one another’s essays.
Directions
1. Turn in one copy of paper to instructor.
2. Take two Peer Review Worksheets.
3. Get into groups of 3-4 Students.
4. Take turns reading papers ALOUD to group.
5. Pass paper clockwise (or counterclockwise if you’re feeling rebellious).
6. Silently read another student’s paper and fill out worksheet.
7. Repeat steps 5 & 6.
Paper Title:_______________________________________________
This paper is ______pages long (excluding Works Cited page)
This paper includes a Works Cited page in MLA format: Yes No
Thesis statement is in paragraph # _____
Copy thesis statement verbatim.
Two enlightening quotations from sources that the author utilized are:
and
Two notable sentences that the author composed are:
and
What is the paper’s strongest feature?
An Amusing Teacher Story
During a discussion about ESP, a student informed the class that he possessed a “sixth scent.” Miraculously, I resisted the temptation to say, “You’re telling me, buddy.” (Life rarely provides such a perfect straight line.)
Are the dishes in the dishwasher clean? Did you forget to turn on the machine? Are the dishes in the dishwasher clean? Why are they foul and obscene? Are the dishes in the dishwasher clean? They lack all luster and sheen. Are the dishes in the dishwasher clean? Why are they yucky moldy green? Are the dishes in the dishwasher clean? You look confused; don’t you know what I mean? Are the dishes in the dishwasher clean?
It would be redundant to say that Dave was “completely devastated” when his hamster died because there cannot be degrees of devastation. I can be extremely scared by radio reports of zombies in my neighborhood, but it would be inexact to say that I am extremely terrified. Conversely, it would be oxymoronic* to declare that Dave was only “slightly devastated” by the news of his hamster’s untimely demise.
For the poet (by which I also of course mean the novelist) the phrases completely devastated and slightly devastated have all sorts of wonderful possibilities. However, writers seeking precision with their words (students enrolled in a Freshman Composition class, for example) should avoid such phrases.
* George Carlin has helpful lists of redundancies and oxymora in his book Braindroppings
Evaluation
State whether the highlighted portions of the following sentences are redundant, oxymoronic, or grammatically acceptable.
1. I was a tad heartbroken when my wife left me for my younger brother.
2. My aunt is a little bit pregnant.
3. Dresden was totally incinerated by the Allied bombing.
4. Pizza is extremely overrated.
5. My cat was completely dead after the accident.
6. Gertrude was a little bit exhausted after studying six straight hours for her English exam.
7. Osvaldo was completely miserable after he lost the tiddlywinks tournament.
8. The traffic around here is somewhat slow after jai alai matches.
9. Pham was extremely furious when I told her the results from Dancing with the Stars.
* 1 cup sugar
* 1 cup canned pumpkin
* 1/4 cup unsweetened applesauce
* 1/4 cup fat free vanilla yogurt
* 2 large egg whites
* 1 1/2 cups all purpose flour
* 1 tsp ground cinnamon
* 3/4 tsp salt
* 1/2 tsp baking soda
* 1/2 cup semisweet chocolate chips
* cooking spray
Preparation
* Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
* Combine first 5 ingredients in a large bowl, and stir well. In a medium bowl, combine flour, cinnamon, salt, and baking soda. Add flour mixture to pumpkin mixture, stirring just until moist. Stir in chocolate chips.
* Spoon batter into a loaf pan coated with cooking spray. Bake for 45-50 minutes or until a wooden pick inserted in the center comes out clean. Cool 10 minutes in pan, then remove. Cool completely on wire rack. Makes 16 slices.
**To make it even healthier, try Splenda instead of sugar! I didn’t want to try it for the first time making it, but the next time I make it I’m going to try this to see how it compares!
I’ve studied all one needs to know ‘bout every little thing
I’ve scoured the biographies of philosophes and kings
I’ve meditated countless hours on all that I have learned
And I’ve concluded modestly that clearly I have earned
The right to state objectively that all I would proclaim
Is exactly what should be, and wouldn’t it be a shame
If Lilliputian intellects and putrid second-raters
Or lily-livered losers and unmanly imitators
Would dare to think that they possess grit and gut and gall
To interrupt my project for the benefit of all?
Undermined by cowards and their miniscule bereavements
Who could not comprehend the scope of my achievement
Like pesky little gnats, they hindered my attention
Allowing mediocrities to cancel my ascension
These trifling mental midgets who dared to halt my plans
Don’t deserve to share the planet with a real fighting man
They can analyze the metrics until the end of time
And never comprehend the dimensions of their crime
When assessing this fiasco, please do not involve me
For I have every confidence that history will absolve me